Skip to Main Content
Sweet Surrender Bake House logo topSweet Surrender Bake House logo scroll
  • Yelp page
  • Order Online
  • Menu
  • Custom Orders
  • Gallery
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Catering
  • Jobs

Our Menu

Bread & RollsBaked SpecialtyCroissantsSconesPiesCakesDanish & MuffinsDonutsCookiesPastries

Bread

Italian Plain

$5.00

Italian Seeded

$5.00

French

$5.00

Rye Plain

$6.50/Small
$13.00/Large

Rye Seeded

$6.50/Small
$13.00/Large

Rye Onion Bread

$6.50

Six Grain

$6.00

Challah

$7.50/Small
$16.00/Large

Semolina

$6.00

Cinnamon Raisin

$7.00

Pumpernickel

$16.00/Large

Rolls

Kaiser Roll

$1.25
Plain, Sesame Seed, Poppy Seed, and Everything

Soft Roll

$1.25
Plain, Sesame Seed, and Poppy Seed

Onion Roll

$1.25

Buttered Roll

$2.25

1/2 Dozen Assorted Rolls

$7.00

12 Assorted Rolls

$14.00

Baked Specialty

Onion Pockets

$1.25

Salt Sticks

$1.75

Chocolate Cigar

$4.00

Brownie

$3.25
Chocolate Chip or Walnut

Brownie

$4.75
Gluten Free

Sfogiatelle

$3.50

Apple Horn

$12.95

Cheese Horn

$12.95

Meltaway

$13.00

Almond Horn Cookie

$4.00

Almond Horn

$12.95/Large
Pecan Ring photo

Pecan Ring

$14.95

Apple Strudel

$14.95

Rainbow Bar

$4.50

Rainbow Crumb Bar

$5.50

Apple Turnover

$2.25/Small
$4.00/Large
$4.25/Large Sugar Free

Blueberry Turnover

$4.00/Large
$4.25/Large Sugar Free

Cinnamon Raisin Buns

$2.00

Cheese Buns

$2.00

Crumb Bun

$2.00

Raspberry Crumb Bar

$3.25

Croissants

Baked Croissant

$3.50

Chocolate Croissant

$3.75

Strawberry Cheese Croissant

$3.75

Jelly Croissant

$3.25

Custard Croissant

$3.25

Scones

Chocolate Chip

$4.00

Blueberry

$4.00

Cranberry Orange

$4.00

Maple Pecan

$4.00

Pies

Apple Pie photo

Apple Pie

$17.95

Cherry Pie

$17.95

Blueberry Pie

$17.95
Apple Crumb photo

Apple Crumb

$17.95

Blueberry Crumb

$17.95

Cherry Crumb

$17.95

Pecan Pie

$22.95

Lemon Meringue

$17.95
Brownie Pie Chocolate Chip photo

Brownie Pie Chocolate Chip

$16.95

Brownie Pie Walnut

$16.95

Brownie Pie Peanut Butter

$16.95

Cookie Dough Brownie Pie

$16.95

Banana Cream Pie

$17.95
Chocolate Cream Pie photo

Chocolate Cream Pie

$17.95

Key Lime Pie

$17.95

Sugar Free Pie

$18.95/Small
$33.50/Large
Preorder

Pound Cakes

Chocolate Drizzle

$15.95

Raspberry Swirl

$15.95

Philly Fluff

$14.95
Plain or Chocolate Chip

Raspberry Crumb

$15.95

Apricot Crumb

$17.95
Preorder

Black & White Cake

$15.95

Crumb Square

$14.95
Plain or Apple

Sugar Free Pound Cake

$18.95
Marble or Blueberry

Apple Cider Cake

$16.95

Cheesecakes

Plain Cheescake

$16.95/Small 6"
$25.00/Large 8"

Fruit Filling Topped Cheesecake

$17.95/Small 6"
$27.00/Large 8"

Marble Cheesecake w/ Ganache

$19.95/Small 6"
$31.50/Large 8"
Rainbow Cheesecake photo

Rainbow Cheesecake

$19.95/Small 6"
$31.50/Large 8"

3 Fruit Filling Topped Cheesecake

$19.95/Small 6"
$31.50/Large 8"

Cheesecake with Fresh Fruit

$19.95/Small 6"
$31.50/Large 8"

S/F Cheesecake

$17.95/Small 6"
$20.95/Small 6" Fruit Filling

Butter Cream Cakes

Pina Colade Cake

$28.95

All Vanilla

$23.95

All Vanilla with Ice Cream Cone

$28.95
Oreo Cake photo

Oreo Cake

$24.95
Shadow Cake photo

Shadow Cake

$24.95

Maple Walnut Cake

$24.95

Mocha Cake

$24.95

Vanilla Coconut Cake

$22.95

Lemon Coconut Cake

$22.95

Dulce de Leche Cake

$25.95

Reeses Peanut Butter Cake

$25.95

German Chocolate Cake

$29.95
Preorder

Hard Icing

$30.95
Preorder

Candy Bar Cake

$29.95

Smores Cake

$29.95

Whipped Cream Cakes

Black Forest Cake

$24.95
Cannoli Cake photo

Cannoli Cake

$23.95

Congo Cake

$24.95

Royal Strawberry Shortcake

$31.95
Strawberry Shortcake photo

Strawberry Shortcake

$24.95
Berry Delight Cake photo

Berry Delight Cake

$28.95

Pecan WC Ring Cake

$19.95

Vanilla Whipped Cream Bomb

$23.95

Cookie Dough Delight Cake

$29.95

Tiramisu

$29.95

Tres Leches

$30.95
Preorder

Royal Tres Leches

$31.95

Fudge Cakes

7 Layer Cake photo

7 Layer Cake

$16.95
Vanilla Swirl photo

Vanilla Swirl

$23.95

All Chocolate

$23.95

7" Cake No Filling- Fudge Frosting

$19.95
Preorder

Custard Cakes

Crumb Custard Cake

$19.95
Napolean Cake photo

Napolean Cake

$24.95
Fruit Tart photo

Fruit Tart

$29.95/Large

Chocolate Ganache Cakes

Raspberry Mousse Cake

$29.95

Java Chip Cake

$29.95
Preorder

Flourless Chocolate Cake

$23.95
Preorder

Rainbow Cannoli Crumb Cake

$31.95

Cookie Cakes

10" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

$29.95
Preorder

Pudding Cakes

Bread Pudding Cake

$17.95

Jelly Donut/Caramel Apple Bread Pudding

$19.95

Semi Sweet Chocolate Cakes

Black Out Cake

$24.95
Dark Chocolate Pudding

Chocolate Mousse

$24.95
Rainbow Cake photo

Rainbow Cake

$25.95

Cream Cheese Cakes

Carrot Cake photo

Carrot Cake

$24.95

Red Velvet

$26.95

Danish

Prune Danish

$3.75

Cinnamon Danish

$3.75

Cheese Danish

$3.75

Pecan Danish

$4.25

Muffins

Sugar Free Blueberry Muffin photo

Sugar Free Blueberry Muffin

$4.00

Sugar Free Marble Muffin

$4.00

Corn Muffin

$3.75

Chocolate Chip Muffin

$3.75

Oat Bran Muffin

$3.75

Apple Muffin

$3.75

Pistachio Muffin

$3.75

Marble Muffin

$3.75

Blueberry Muffin

$3.75

Donuts

Jelly Donut

$2.25

Boston Cream Donut

$2.25

Chocolate Glazed Donut

$2.25

Vanilla Glazed Donut

$2.25

Chocolate Glazed Sprinkle Donut

$2.25

Vanilla Glazed Sprinkle Donut

$2.25

Double Filled Marble Donut

$2.50

Double Filled Strawberry Donut

$2.50

Powder Sugar Donut

$2.25
Jelly or Cream

Cinnamon Sugar Donut

$2.25

Cannoli Donut

$4.75

Twists/Round Donut

$2.25

French Cruller

$3.00
Chocolate or Vanilla
Speciality Donut photo

Speciality Donut

$4.75
Pistachio, Cotton Candy, The Elvis, Cocoloco Caramel, Death by Chocolate, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Cannoli, Rainbow Cannoli, Candy Apple, or Caramel Apple

1/2 Dozen Assorted Donuts

$12.50

12 Assorted Donuts

$25.00

Cookies

Gluten Free Cookie

$4.75

Vegan Cookie

$4.75

Triple Chunk Cookie

$4.00

Fudge Mountain Cookie

$4.00

Reese's Cookie

$4.00

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

$4.00

Character Cookie

$4.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.50

Rainbow Sprinkled Cookie

$3.00

Black & White

$4.00

Linzer Tart

$3.50

Royal Iced Cookie

$5.50

1/2 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies

$7.50

1/2 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies Nut Free

$7.50

1/2 LB Box of Sugar Free Small Chocolate Chip Cookies

$7.50

1/2 LB Box of Rainbow Cookies

$11.00

1 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies

$17.95

1 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies Nut Free

$17.95

1 LB Box of Rainbow Cookies

$21.95

Small Cookie Tray

$19.00
Little under 1 lb

Medium Cookie Tray

$28.50
Over 1.5 lb

Large Cookie Tray

$38.50
Over 2 lb

3LB Cookie Tray

$57.00

5LB Cookie Tray

$96.00

Rugelach

$21.95

Pignoli

$37.95

Hamentashen

$4.00
Prune, Raspberry, or Apricot

Almond Horn

$4.00

Coconut Macaroon

$4.00/Large
$18.95/Small

Pastries

Cupcakes- Red Velvet

$4.00
Preorder

Cupcakes- Chocolate

$3.00

Cupcakes- Vanilla

$3.00

Cupcakes- Filled Chocolate

$3.75

Cupcakes- Filled Vanilla

$3.75

Cupcakes- Funfetti

$4.00

Cupcakes- Pistachio

$4.00

Cannoli

$2.95/Small
$5.00/Large

Eclair

$2.50/Small
$5.00/Large

Napolean

$2.50/Small
$5.00/Large

Cream Puff

$2.50

Creme Brulee

$5.00

Creme Brulee

$35.00
10" Preorder

Cake Pops

$3.50
Chocolate, Red Velvet, Cookie Dough, Funfetti, or Oreo

Key Lime Tart

$5.00

Chocolate Mousse

$5.00

Black Out Pastry

$5.00

Strawberry Tart

$5.00

Mixed Fruit Tart

$5.00

Tiramisu Pastry

$5.50

Carrot Cake Pastry

$5.00

Mini Cheesecake

$5.00

Cup of Cappuccino/Hazelnut Pastry

$5.80

Oreo Mousse Cup

$5.80

Peanut Butter Mousse Cup

$5.80

Lobster Tails

$5.50

Cannoli Cookie Sandwich

$5.50

Sugar Free Parfait

$5.00

Mini Bread Pudding

$5.00
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs